Ledger Domain: How and Why Marketers Can Improve Their Implementations of the Blockchain

Looking At Milky Way, Image by Wall Boat

Is there any product, service or technology out there today that’s just a click away from offering people the virtual equivalent of a cure for the common cold that costs less than a dollar and tastes better than chocolate? No, of course not. But as new innovations inevitably rise and fall along the waves of the tech hype cycle, the true potential of The Next Big Tech Thing often takes years to become fully realized and optimized for a deep and wide variety of markets.

One of today’s leading candidates competing for this top-level billing is the blockchain.¹ It is enjoying massive media buzz, investment and experimentation in configuring it for a diversity of applications including, among many others, food supply chains, financial services and artists rights. This technology is providing new means to accomplish business tasks more securely and reliably, thus increasing operational efficiencies.

Yet whether the blockchain can and will fully and effectively scale in all circumstances still remains to be seen by many sectors of the business world. An inherently key question at the very heart of the blockchain’s growth and acceptance is whether marketers and advertisers can leverage many of its technological virtues and, if so, how they can best accomplish this?

Taking a deeply insightful and informative look at of the latest developments concerning this is a highly informative recent article entitled How Blockchain Can Help Marketers Build Better Relationships with Their Customers, by Campbell R. Harvey, Christine Moorman and Marc Toledo, posted on the Harvard Business Review website on October 1, 2018. I highly recommend a click-through and full read if you have an opportunity.

I will summarize and annotate this, reference in some related Subway Fold posts, and then pose some of my own ad-free questions.

The Benefits of Diminishing Transaction Costs

Economic Gardening, Image by Missy Schmidt

According to a February 2018 CMO Survey, just 8% of its participants rated the usage of the blockchain in their marketing operations as being “moderately or very important”. This technology is still “not well understood” among marketers and perceived as being over-hyped. This has resulted in a “wait and see” attitude about it. Nonetheless, there are compelling reasons to understand the blockchain and build specific marketing applications for it that will be more likely to benefit early adopters and innovators.

The blockchain’s virtues of “transparency, immutability and security” make it very suitable for a wide range of transactional and managerial functions. Likewise, it lowers the costs involved in executing all of these activities and, even more importantly, the need to rely so heavily on the web’s giant advertising intermediaries (primarily Google and Facebook), may be reduced. As well, the means now exist using this technology to permit consumers to better “own and control” their personal data.²

Currently, electronic transactions using credit and debit cards involve significant costs to online and real-world vendors. These associated costs are passed along to consumers. Sellers often set minimum purchase thresholds to maintain their profitability.

However, the transactional costs of using the blockchain are approaching zero. For example, MasterCard and Visa have implemented blockchain-based alternative systems enabling customers to “send money in any local currency”, without using a credit card. This again removes any embedded intermediaries and “connects directly to the banks” involved. Consequently, cross-border fees can be dispensed.

There are other advantages emerging for marketers and advertisers involving exchanges of real monetary value with consumers. Rather than these professionals all relying on third-parties such as Facebook for acquiring troves of customer data, they could instead use a system of micropayments³ to directly reward consumers for their personal data. For instance, under this alternative model, a supermarket chain could provide shoppers with a mobile app that pays them to install it, tracks their location, and use it for special deals on merchandise at personalized prices4.

Similarly, marketers could employ the use of smart contracts that vitiate the “need for validation, review, or authentication by intermediaries”. These can be engaged when participants subscribe to an email newsletter or customer rewards program. (More on this below.) The micropayments here are dispensed to consumers whenever they respond to a vendor’s emails or advertisements.

Like Flamingo Synapses, Image by Donal Mountain

Alleviating Google’s and Facebook’s Dominance in Online Advertising

This direct-reward-to-consumers architecture could similarly be deployed for the engagement of website ads. Presently, most users are put off by the current system of intrusive pop-ups and other forms of unavoidable online advertising. A growing Web-wide push back to this has been the use of ad-blocking browser add-ons.5

New alternatives based upon the blockchain can “recapture” some this lost ad revenue by directly compensating online consumers “for their attention”6. This could potentially diminish Google’s and Facebook’s lock on the majority of online ad and data revenues.7 Blockchain options will also enable individuals to “control their own online profiles and social graphs”.8

Taken together, these possibilities might permit companies to:

  • interact directly with their consumers
  • bypass patronizing the social media and search giants, and
  • avoid relentless email solicitations and “follow-me ads”

Furthermore, meaningful cost savings can be directly passed along to consumers by virtue of this voluntarily consumed advertising via these types of blockchain-supported conduits.

Image from Pixabay.com

Shutting Down Online Frauds and Spam

By 2016, $7.6 billion was appropriated by “fraudulent or deceptive activity” and is expected to increase soon to nearly $11 billion. Nonetheless, marketing teams who deploy the blockchain to “track their ads” can:

  • maintain control over their online activities
  • be more confident that expenditures are going to “ROI-generating activities”, and
  • measure the effects of their efforts on a per-user and per-mail scale

Thus, to the benefit of marketers and vendors and to the detriment of bad actors online are the following technological advantages:

Verification: The blockchain can be used to provide verification of “the origin and methodology of marketers”. It can likewise reduce or eliminate large-scale phishing spam through the use of micropayments to the recipients of marketing emails. This will enable “companies to identify consumers” who are genuinely interested in their offerings. Micropayments could then be dispensed in exchange for access to various forms of onscreen content.

Security: Such implementations could also potentially defeat malicious hacks using denial of service attacks (DoS) and could make social media sites more resistant to automated bot accounts. The former are attempts to overwhelm web servers with a flood of traffic and latter are widely used for massive distributions of deceptive information, as well as to illegally appropriate “online advertising from big brands”.

Authenticity: A user’s bonafides is one of the main cornerstones of the blockchain. Turning this into a service, Keybase.io is a company currently working on reducing social media fraud. Their blockchain-enabled app permits individual users to prove they are the “rightful owners” of various social media account. This makes marketing easier to monitor and advertising expenses more supportable.

“Origami Fish – Made by June”, image by Penny

Increasing Revenues from Media Viewership

Original and editorial web content built upon blockchain technology can potentially permit media companies to increase their “quality control and copyright protection”.9 For example, Kodak has developed a new product called KODAKOne, an image rights and distribution platform. It uses the blockchain to record the ownership rights to individual images. Photographers will be awarded greater control over their work than they currently have with how their pictures distribution online. In the future, photographers will automatically be sent payments whenever their content is used. This could probably also be used for video content creators whose work has gone viral.

A company called Coupit also uses blockchain tech to enable marketers to join loyalty and affiliate programs whereby consumers can opt-in and “trade rewards with each other”. As a result, marketers can increase their “visibility and transparency” in order to distinguish inactive from loyal consumers. They can next sharpen their marketing strategies to distribute “targeted offers” to each of these categories.

In those cases where marketers employ a data aggregator or analytics processor, using micropayments will permit companies to circumvent ad-blocking apps10. For consumers, this gives then more fine-point control over their personal data and privacy, and rewards them for their willingness to view advertising that they have chosen.

Taking an alternative approach to content monetization is a new web browser called Brave. In addition to providing many built-in privacy and security features, it contains a blockchain-based feature called Basic Attention Tokens (BATs). These enable “publishers to monetize value added services” whereby users can dispense these tokens to sites they choose for content they select.

“The Crystal Ball”, Image by Gyorgy Soponyai

Companies and Consumers are Both Beneficiaries

Along with the progression of the blockchain’s reach and capabilities, business “intermediaries will need to adapt” accordingly. As discussed above, consumers will be exercising increased control and discretion over how they decide to engage with advertisers and Web threats such as spam and phishing will become self-limiting as their current tactics will be economically undermined.

Balancing this power and attention shift, companies might be able to exert greater control over the “quality of inbound traffic” to their marketing programs and achieve greater understanding of their customers’ needs and motivations.  When pursuing such “high value customers”, these economic incentives will perhaps result in a correspondingly increase in value.

Given all of these advantages that marketers and advertisers have to gain from further embracing blockchain technology, “finding ways to design and implement” them should be a joint effort among corporate decision-makers not just in marketing but also from the strategy, finance and technology departments. Moreover, innovative applications of the blockchain may ultimately be more beneficially in connecting marketers and advertisers with their intended audiences in ways that may have not been otherwise previously possible.

My Questions

  • Given that Google and Facebook currently have an overwhelming lock on online advertising’s multi-$billion revenue streams, will they meet any potential challenges to this with their own blockchain-founded variants? If so, how might they be different in their approach to benefit both advertisers and consumers? At the very least, do they even perceive this as a legitimate threat to their business models?
  • In addition to rewarding consumers with micropayments for ad clicks and content views, what, if anything, could companies do to correspondingly build incentives into their pricing structures for consumers’ purchasers? How should pricing be affected for repeat or bulk purchases by consumers? What if consumers make referrals of additional interested consumers to these blockchain-based vendors?
  • Would using mixed media such as augmented reality and virtual reality lend themselves to blockchain-based marketing implementations to further attract new potential consumers? That is, in return for micropayments disbursed to capture users’ attention, might enhanced advertising or content consumption experiences benefit both advertisers and consumers who would both end up feeling as though they are receiving added value for their participation?
  • What new entrepreneurial opportunities for goods, services and technologies might arise from these new and extensible blockchain-based marketing capabilities?

 


1.  Some examples of earlier implementations of blockchain technology were covered in these Subway Fold posts.

2.  X-ref to the concluding paragraph of the June 7, 2018 Subway Fold post entitled Single File, Everyone: The Advent of the Universal Digital Profile, concerning another innovative effort to return full control of personal data to consumers called the Hub of All Things. Two other similar startups that have emerged during the past few weeks are Inrupt and Helm. This is starting to become a very interesting and innovative space. Furthermore, there was a fascinating and far-ranging article in The New York Times on October 19, 2018, entitled How the Blockchain Could Break Big Tech’s Hold on A.I., by Nathaniel Popper, exploring the possibility of using the blockchain as a means for individuals to control and distribute some of their personal information to be used in AI databases.

3.  Virtual reality pioneer, Microsoft scientist and author Jaron Lanier presented a persuasive case for this, among many other thought-provoking insights about the digital world, in his book entitled Who Owns the Future? (Simon & Schuster, 2013). Highly recommended reading if you have an opportunity.

4Amazon constantly and widely varies it prices based on all of the personal and market data they have accumulated as reported in an article posted on BusinessInsider.com on August 10, 2018, entitled Amazon Changes Prices on Its Products About Every 10 minutes — Here’s How and Why They Do It, by Neel Mehta, Parth Detroja, and Aditya Agashe.

5.  For example, AdBlock and Ghostery, among others, are browser add-ons that can effectively remove nearly all online ads. These apps are continually updated by their developers.

6.  Columbia University Law School professor and New York Times contributing opinion writer Tim Wu wrote a highly engaging book on the past, present and future of how advertising and mass media compete for our attention entitled The Attention Merchants The Attention Merchants: The Epic Scramble to Get Inside Our Heads, (Alfred A. Knopf, 2016). It is very worthwhile reading for its originality and insights.

7.  See the July 25, 2018 Subway Fold post entitled Book Review of “Frenemies: The Epic Disruption of the Ad Business (and Everything Else)” for more detailed coverage on the current state of the online advertising market.

8.  See again the June 7, 2018 Subway Fold post entitled Single File, Everyone: The Advent of the Universal Digital Profile for some of the emerging innovative alternatives in this space.

9.  See also these Subway Fold posts in the category of Intellectual Property.

10.  See the August 13, 2015 Subway Fold post entitled New Report Finds Ad Blockers are Quickly Spreading and Costing $Billions in Lost Revenue.

“Technographics” – A New Approach for B2B Marketers to Profile Their Customers’ Tech Systems

"Gold Rings - Sphere 1" Image by Linda K

“Gold Rings – Sphere 1” Image by Linda K

Today’s marketing and business development professionals use a wide array of big data collection and analytical tools to create and refine sophisticated profiles of market segments and their customer bases. These are deployed in order to systematically and scientifically target and sell their goods and services in steadily changing marketplaces.

These processes can include, among a multitude of other vast data sets and methodologies, demographics, web user metrics and econometrics. Businesses are always looking for a data-driven edge in highly competitive sectors and such profiling, when done correctly, can be very helpful in detecting and interpreting market trends, and consistently keeping ahead of their rivals. (The Subway Fold category of Big Data and Analytics now contains 50 posts about a variety of trends and applications in this field.)

I will briefly to this add my own long-term yet totally unscientific study of office-mess-ographics. Here I have been looking for any correlation between the relative states of organization – – or entropy – – in people’s offices and their work’s quality and output.  The results still remain inconclusive after years of study.

One of the most brilliant and accomplished people I have ever known had an office that resembled a cave deep in the earth with piles of paper resembling stalagmites all over it. Even more remarkably, he could reach into any one of those piles and pull out exactly the documents he wanted. His work space was so chaotic that there was a long-standing joke that Jimmy Hoffa’s and Judge Crater’s long-lost remains would be found whenever ever he retired and his office was cleaned out.

Speaking of office-focused analytics, an article posted on VentureBeat.com on March 5, 2016, entitled CMOs: ‘Technographics’ is the New Demographics, by Sean Zinsmeister, brought news of a most interesting new trend. I highly recommend reading this in its entirety. I will summarize and add some context to it, and then pose a few question-ographics of my own.

New Analytical Tool for B2B Marketers

Marketers are now using a new methodology call technography to analyze their customers’ “tech stack“, a term of art for the composition of their supporting systems and platforms. The objective of this approach is to deeply understand what this says about them as a company and, moreover, how can this be used in business-to-business (B2B) marketing campaigns. Thus applied, technography can identify “pain points” in products and alleviate them for current and prospective customers.

Using established consumer marketing methods, there is much to be learned and leveraged on how technology is being used by very granular segments of users bases.  For example:

By virtue of this type of technographic data, retailers can target their ads in anticipation of “which customers are most likely to shop in store, online, or via mobile”.

Next, by transposing this form of well-established marketing approach next upon B2B commerce, the objective is to carefully examine the tech stacks of current and future customers in order to gain a marketing advantage. That is, to “inform” a business’s strategy and identify potential new roles and needs to be met. These corporate tech stacks can include systems for:

  • Office productivity
  • Project management
  • Customer relationship management (CRM)
  • Marketing

Gathering and Interpreting Technographic Signals and Nuances

Technographics can provide unique and valuable insights into assessing, for example, whether a customer values scalability or ease-of-use more, and then act upon this.

As well, some of these technographic signals can be indicative of other factors not, per se, directly related to technology. This was the case at Eloqua, a financial technology concern. They noticed their marketing systems have predictive value in determining the company’s best prospects. Furthermore, they determined that companies running their software were inclined “to have a certain level of technological sophistication”, and were often large enough to have the capacity to purchase higher-end systems.

As business systems continually grow in their numbers and complexity, interpreting technographic nuances has also become more of a challenge. Hence, the application of artificial intelligence (AI) can be helpful in detecting additional useful patterns and trends. In a July 2011 TED Talk by Ted Slavin, directly on point here, entitled How Algorithms Shape Our World, he discussed how algorithms and machine learning are needed today to help make sense out of the massive and constantly growing amounts of data. (The Subway Fold category of Smart Systems contains 15 posts covering recent development and applications involving AI and machine learning.)

Technographic Resources and Use Cases

Currently, technographic signals are readily available from various data providers including:

They parse data using such factors as “web hosting, analytics, e-commerce, advertising, or content management platforms”. Another firm called Ghostery has a Chrome browser extension illuminating the technologies upon which any company’s website is built.

The next key considerations are to “define technographic profiles and determine next-best actions” for specific potential customers. For instance, an analytics company called Looker creates “highly targeted campaigns” aimed at businesses who use Amazon Web Services (AWS). The greater the number of marketers who undertake similar pursuits, the more they raise the value of their marketing programs.

Technographics can likewise be applied for competitive leverage in the following use cases:

  • Sales reps prospecting for new leads can be supported with more focused messages for potential new customers. These are shaped by understanding their particular motivations and business challenges.
  • Locating opportunities in new markets can be achieved by assessing the tech stacks of prospective customers. Such analytics can further be used for expanding business development and product development. An example is the online training platform by Mindflash. They detected a potential “demand for a Salesforce training program”. Once it became available, they employed technographic signals to pinpoint customers to whom they could present it.
  • Enterprise wide decision-making benefits can be achieved by adding “value in areas like cultural alignment”. Familiarity with such data for current employees and job seekers can aid businesses with understanding the “technology disposition” of their workers. Thereafter, its alignment with the “customers or partners” can be pursued.  Furthermore, identifying areas where additional training might be needed can help to alleviate productivity issues resulting from “technology disconnects between employees”.

Many businesses are not yet using technographic signals to their full advantage. By increasing such initiatives, businesses can acquire a much deeper understanding of their inherent values. In turn, the resulting insights can have a significant effect on the experiences of their customers and, in turn, elevate their resulting levels of loyalty, retention and revenue, as well as the magnitude of deals done.

My Questions

  • Would professional service industries such as law, medicine and accounting, and the vendors selling within these industries, benefit from integrating technographics into their own business development and marketing efforts?
  • Could there be, now or in the future, an emerging role for dedicated technographics specialists, trainers and consultants? Alternatively, should these new analytics just be treated as another new tool to be learned and implemented by marketers in their existing roles?
  • If a company identifies some of their own employees who might benefit from additional training, how can they be incentivized to participate in it? Could gamification techniques also be applied in creating these training programs?
  • What, if any, privacy concerns might surface in using technographics on potential customer leads and/or a company’s own internal staff?